Sophie has a busy employment practice. Whilst she has vast experience in an array of matters, she has gained particular experience in whistleblowing, discrimination, TUPE, dismissal cases (constructive unfair or wrongful) and unlawful deductions.
Sophie’s experience extends to all stages of litigation and her advisory work has included:
- Advising on the employment status of two individuals providing services through a partnership.
- Advising on whether there was likely to be a service provision change and therefore TUPE
- Advising on the employment implications of changing terms and conditions to employees (where TUPEand collective agreements were relevant).
- Advising on the Employment (Allocation of Tips) Bill and its potential implications on the client’s business and remuneration terms.
- Advising on matters related to the calculation of the national minimum wage.
- Advising on the legality of an initiative which relied on the positive-action provisions of the Equality Act.
Sophie has substantial drafting experience, and has drafted Grounds of Complaint or Grounds of Resistance including the following:
- Drafting two Grounds of Resistance for a respondent in a later consolidated TUPE-related dispute on the basis that there was no relevant transfer.
- Drafting Grounds of Complaints for constructive unfair dismissal, maternity and pregnancy discrimination, detriment and automatic unfair dismissal (involving claims brought under ERA 1996 and MAPLR 1999).
- Drafting a Grounds of Complaint in relation to the failure to inform and consult (under the TUPE 2006 regulations), failure to collectively consult (under TULR(C)A 1992), as well as for automatic and ordinary unfair dismissal.
- Drafting Grounds of Resistance denying that the individual was an employee and therefore not entitled to the compensation sought.
- Drafting various Grounds of Resistance in claims for unfair dismissal (conduct and redundancy related dismissals), constructive unfair dismissal, discrimination (pertaining to most protected characteristics and involving claims pursuant tos.13, 15, 18, 19, 20, and 26 Equality Act 2010), victimisation, and whistleblowing detriment.
Sophie regularly appears in the Employment Tribunal for preliminary hearings and multi-day final hearings, appearing for claimants and respondents (both individual or corporate). Examples of her advocacy experience includes:
- Making and resisting applications for anonymity orders;
- Drafting skeleton argument in respect of a wasted costs application;
- Making applications for strike out or deposit orders. Including successfully striking out a claimant’s claim for non-compliance with tribunal orders, and another claim for failure to bring the claim within the time limits;
- Successfully arguing there had been a TUPE transfer in respect of an employee who had been employed at a fitness centre;
- Successfully striking out claimants’ claims in relation to employment status;
- Successfully representing a respondent in a two-day constructive unfair dismissal claim, and another respondent in a three-day unfair dismissal claim;
- Representing other respondents in multi-day unfair and/or wrongful dismissal claims;
- Acting as junior counsel representing multiple respondents in a two-week whistleblowing, unfair dismissal and disability discrimination claim;
- Representing a claimant in his unfair and wrongful dismissal claim;
- Representing a respondent in a claim for automatic unfair dismissal (relating to pregnancy, childbirth or maternity);
- Successfully acting for a respondent in a hearing to determine claims of direct race discrimination and unauthorised deduction of wages;
- Preparing for a four-day hearing to determine the claimant’s complaint of indirect race discrimination and victimisation;
- Successfully representing respondent in a four-day claim for race, sex or age discrimination;
- Successfully representing respondent in a four-day unfair dismissal and disability discrimination The issues had been refined following obtaining strike out and/or deposit orders in relation to certain aspects of the claim at a previous preliminary hearing;
- Successfully representing three respondents at a seven-day hearing to determine complaints of race discrimination, victimisation, unlawful deduction of wages and unfair dismissal.
Sophie has also represented clients at judicial mediation preliminary hearings, which have successfully resulted in the settlement of claims.
Sophie has a particular interest in cases that involve international elements, for instance she has:
- Acted as a junior in an age discriminationand whistleblowing claim which was resisted on the grounds of diplomatic immunity;
- Drafted grounds of resistance and advised in a matter which involved consideration of the State Immunity Act 1978; and
- Assisted in a claim brought in the DFIC involving claims of underpayment of bonus, breach of whistleblower protections, unlawful competition, and misuse of confidential information.
In addition to statutory employment, Sophie has experience with business protection and High Court litigation. For example, Sophie was a junior in High Court litigation (led by Gavin Mansfield KC, and with Matthew Sheridan and Alex Francis) involving two departing executives and allegations of breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duties and unlawful means conspiracy.